Notre Dame Stadium in South Bend, IN

Basic Information

Stadium: Notre Dame Stadium

Location: South Bend, IN (41.69813, -86.23399)

Owner: University of Notre Dame

Primary sport: football

Year constructed: 1930; last major renovation 2017

Listed capacity: 77,622

Date last visited: September 2024

Stadium information: https://fightingirish.com/facilities-notre-dame-stadium-html/

Summary Review: 5 stars (out of 5)

The Cathedral of College Football.  The Knute Rockne Gate.  "Play like a champion today."  The golden dome.  Touchdown Jesus.  The great thing about college football is that every university has its own unique tradition, but few universities have as much college football tradition as Notre Dame.  A football program with this much tradition could rest on its laurels and make the gameday experience the same as it was in 1980, but Notre Dame hasn't done that.  Instead, watching a game at the Cathedral of College Football offers an intriguing blend of the old and the new, the sacred and the secular.  The stadium was completely reconstructed in 2017, and it's construction/design is as good as any stadium in college football.  They take you live via video into the locker room when the team recites the "Lord's prayer" before the game, but the music they boom through the loud speakers was a number 1 hit on the pop charts less than 2 years ago.  Concessions offer both unique and traditional fare.  The team I support was the visiting team and a heavy underdog when I came here.  Did my team come out of South Bend with a win?  No.  Did I care?  Yes, but not really.  I had a great time in Notre Dame Stadium, and every college football fan should come here at least once.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: The stadium atmosphere is an amazing mix of the ancient and the present.  They take you live into the locker room when the team recites the "Lord's prayer" before they take the field.  Yet the music they boom through the loud speakers just before the team runs out of the locker room was a number 1 pop hit less than 2 years ago.  The marching band's uniforms and pregame show are similar to yesteryear, and the field is painted similar to the 1930's.  Yet they use an on-field host to keep fans engaged during time outs.  I really can't think of many universities that provide a fan experience that can compete with Notre Dame's.

Seating: mostly bench seating.  The rows are reasonably wide and provide good access to seats away from the aisles.

Field View: My seats were in the upper deck of the north end zone, which are literally the worst seats in the stadium.  Yet considering where I was, I had a decent view of the field.

Audio/Video: The audio system is as clear and loud as any stadium system I have heard.  There is 1 large and excellent video board at the south end of the stadium.

Concessions/Hot Dogs: The hot dogs are large and juicy, but they cost $6, so they had better be.  The concessions are on the concourse behind the stands where you would expect them, and there are plenty of concession areas throughout the stadium.  Other than the cost, there isn't much to complain about on the concessions.

Pedestrian Flow: wide and gradually sloped ramps get people to the upper deck, and I had a quick and easy time getting in and out of the stadium in spite of the capacity crowd.

Parking: There is no free parking anywhere near campus, and the cheapest gameday parking is $30.  They do run shuttle busses to some remote lots, but most lots are within a mile of the stadium.  Thus, most people including me prefer to walk.

Memorial Stadium in Clemson, SC

Basic Information

Stadium: Memorial Stadium

Location: Clemson, SC (34.67908, -82.84333)

Owner: Clemson University

Primary sport: football

Year constructed: 1942

Listed capacity: 81,500

Date last visited: April 2024

Stadium information: https://clemsontigers.com/sports/football/facilities/memorial-stadium/

(Aside: I am sorry about the first 2 pictures.  I hope to get back to Clemson and take some new ones at some point.)

Summary Review: 5 stars (out of 5)

Many big and old college football stadiums consist of a patchwork of pieces built at different times that have been glued together, but Memorial Stadium is remarkably unified for a structure of its age.  The stadium features only 2 levels of seating, unlike most stadiums of its size that feature at least 3.  The stadium is located on a natural hillside, so you can enter either at the field level (west side) or at the middle level (east side).  Thus, pedestrian flow is quite good.  Most seats offer a better than expected view of the field due to the stadium's design.  The video and audio systems are second to none, though the concession options could be improved.  Many people view Clemson as an SEC or Big 10 football program playing in the ACC, and indeed the fan support this program enjoys is as good as any in its conference.  Memorial Stadium is my favorite place to watch a football game in the Carolinas, and it is worth coming here if you get the chance.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: almost incomparable.  Clemson football has a large and enthusiastic fan base.  They have a small but loud cannon.  Like most major college football programs, watching a game here is an all-day affair due to crowd size and traffic.  Howard's Rock and the run down the hill is one of the best stadium entrances for any team anywhere.

Seating: mostly bench seating, a few have backs; some chairback seating in the expensive areas of the stadium.

Field View: the seating is built at a sharper than usual arc relative to the sidelines, so every seat feels closer to midfield than it actually is.  The seating also has a fairly steep grade.

Audio/Video: this stadium has a great new video board on the east end with 2 smaller video boards on the west end.  The audio is as good as any large stadium I have been in.

Concessions/Hot Dogs: located in the concourse behind the stands, where you would expect them.  They serve mostly just the usual fare.  The menu is easy to read.  The hot dogs were satisfactory but nothing more. 

Pedestrian Flow: wide concourses and plenty of entrances, so foot traffic flows pretty well.

Parking: there is parking everywhere, but little of it is free.  As with any major college football stadium, it will take awhile to enter or exit before/after the game due to traffic.

Rock Hill Sports and Event Center in Rock Hill, SC

Basic Information

Arena: Rock Hill Sports and Event Center

Location: 326 Technology Center Way in downtown Rock Hill, SC (34.93269, -81.03000)

Owner: City of Rock Hill

Primary sport: basketball

Year constructed: 2020

Listed capacity: 700

Date last visited: March 2024

Arena information: https://www.cityofrockhill.com/Home/Components/FacilityDirectory/FacilityDirectory/84/8145

Summary Review: 2 stars (out of 5)

Rock Hill Sports and Event Center is a common indoor venue for AAU basketball and other travel/amateur indoor sports.  As usual for this kind of venue, the seats on the sidelines are retractable to allow for expanding the floor space when games are not being played.  Some of the seats are tight and uncomfortable, and some other seats have partially obstructed views due to hand railings.  I have definitely sat in better-designed seating.  The video system is satisfactory, but the audio system needs an upgrade in terms of clarity/quality.  Beware of the nearby parking garages: they may or may not be free, and you need to register your car with the electronic parking service provider before you walk to the arena to avoid expensive fines.  Overall, Rock Hill Sports and Event Center is a passable small venue for indoor sports, and I mostly enjoyed the conference basketball tournament I watched here.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: I came here for a conference basketball tournament, so the atmosphere was a little sterile, as you would expect for a neutral site.  The arena reverberates sound pretty well, so it can get loud if the crowd gets into it.

Seating: All plastic seats have backs.  The temporary ones on the sides are tight and uncomfortable, especially for a large man such as I.  The permanent ones in the corners and ends are more comfortable, but of course they offer a worse view.  So I ended up having to choose between a good view of the court and a comfortable seat.  I (eventually) chose the comfortable seat.

Court View: Railings on some of the sections can partially block your view.  Otherwise, the court view is what you would expect given the location of the seat.

Audio/Video: The audio is moderately loud but low quality.  The public address announcer sounded garbled and hard to understand.  The arena has 4 small video screens, one in each corner.  The screens give basic information (time, score, foul counts) but nothing else.

Concessions/Hot Dogs: The arena offers no hot dogs, only pizza, Chick-fil-a sandwiches, 20-ounce sodas, and candy.  The pizza is Ledo Pizza, which is one of my favorite pizzas in the Mid-Atlantic.  The prices are down right cheap for a city-owned basketball arena.

Pedestrian Flow: A walking path goes all the way around the top of the seating, and there are plenty of entrances/exits.  Thus, pedestrian traffic flows pretty well here.

Parking: 2 large parking garages are just a short walk away.  They were free when I came here, but they aren't always free.  Make sure you register your car using the QR code on the signs when you arrive: payment is taken and enforced electronically, and fines for failing to pay are severe.

Peden Stadium in Athens, OH

Basic Information

Stadium: Peden Stadium

Location: Athens, OH (39.32102, -82.10294)

Owner: Ohio University

Primary sport: football

Year constructed: 1929

Listed capacity: 24,000

Date last visited: October 2023

Stadium information: https://ohiobobcats.com/facilities/peden-stadium/8

Summary Review: 1.5 stars (out of 5)

Peden Stadium is the oldest stadium in the Mid American Conference (MAC), and in fact the stadium has been designated an Ohio Historic Site.  Unfortunately, this stadium also looks and feels like an historic site, and that's not a compliment even though I tend to like older stadiums.  Some of the bench seating looks like it dates to 1929 although it probably doesn't.  Only the first few rows of bench seating have backs, which is kind of odd: the people with some of the worst views of the field have some of the most comfortable seats.  There is very little leg room between rows, but the seating area has a very gradual grade.  Thus, each seat feels further from the field than you would expect for its location.  The audio and video systems need upgraded.  On the bright side, Peden Stadium occupies a scenic location overlooking a golf course and the Hocking River.  Nevertheless, this is not a great place to watch a game if you actually want to watch the game, and I would prefer to be in almost any MAC stadium over this one.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: Ohio University has a mid-stepping marching band, which is kind of rare in this part of the country.  There was a pretty large crowd when they were playing archrival Miami on Halloween weekend, but the crowd was still pretty flat.  A light rain may have dampened their spirits a little.

Seating: mostly bench seating; some benches near the field have backs.  A few old chairback seats are in the high dollar parts of the stadium.

Field View: the stands have a gradual grade, so you are a long distance from field relative to your position in the stands.  Thus, the field view is not great.

Audio/Video: the audio is about average.  They have a single small video board in one end zone, so the video system needs upgraded.

Concessions/Hot Dogs: Peden Stadium has plump juicy hot dogs. They also serve brats, which is a nice touch at a college football stadium.

Pedestrian Flow: this stadium has walkways both near the front of and behind the seating area, so pedestrian traffic flows quite well.  I had no trouble getting in or out of the stadium.

Parking: most parking is to the north due to the river to the south.  There is no free parking on campus, but you could walk/bike in on the bikeway that runs along the Hocking River just south of the stadium.

Waldo Stadium in Kalamazoo, MI

Basic Information

Stadium: Waldo Stadium

Location: Kalamazoo, MI (42.28552, -85.60091)

Owner: Western Michigan University

Primary sport: football

Year constructed: 1939

Listed capacity: 30,200

Date last visited: October 2023

Stadium information: https://wmubroncos.com/facilities/waldo-stadium/4

Summary Review: 4 stars (out of 5)

Built in 1939, Waldo Stadium is one of the oldest stadiums in the Mid-American Conference (MAC).  Unlike some other older stadiums, Waldo Stadium offers a great mix of old and new.  The main (south) stands are built on the side of a hill, so you enter the south stands from the top but the rest of the seating from near field level.  You see this bowl or semi-bowl design in many older stadiums; see Sanford Stadium in Athens, GA or Nippert Stadium in Cincinnati, OH for example.  It is an old-fashioned way of improving the pedestrian flow, but it still works.  The stands are graded steeply, so every seat gives a good view of the field relative to its position in the stadium.  The stadium takes an interesting approach with video boards; it uses several smaller video boards rather than 1 big one.  Such an approach is unusual, but again it seems to work.  Like many MAC schools, Western Michigan does not enjoy the fan support it did a couple of decades ago.  That fact plus the fact that Waldo is one of the larger stadiums in the MAC makes it feel a little empty and cavernous.  That said, I enjoyed watching a game here even in rainy weather, and you will probably enjoy coming here too.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: Western Michigan has a very friendly fan base, even to opposing fans.  After walking into the stadium, I accidentally dropped my gloves while trying to put my ticket/phone away.  Another fan pointed them out and picked them up for me!  The marching band sounds great with lots of brass.  The stadium's size created a lot of empty seats on the rainy afternoon I came here, so it felt a little cavernous.  They could probably tarp-over a few thousand seats to make the stadium seem more occupied.

Seating: mostly bench seating.  Some benches have backs, and there is some chair seating.

Field View: the stands are graded steeply, so most seats are elevated well above field relative to their position in the stadium.  Thus, most seats give a good view of the field.

Audio/Video: 3 small video boards; loud audio system

Concessions/Hot Dogs: the beef hot dogs are not super big, but they have a pleasant flavor.  They also serve brats, which is a nice menu item for a college football stadium.

Pedestrian Flow: fans can enter from both the top and the bottom of the main stands, so pedestrian flow is very good.

Parking: $10, all on the south side of the stadium because of its location on the edge of campus.

McGuirk Alumni Stadium in Amherst, MA

Basic Information

Stadium: McGuirk Alumni Stadium

Location: Amherst, MA (42.37727, -72.53604)

Owner: University of Massachusetts Amherst

Primary sport: football

Year constructed: 1965

Listed capacity: 17,000

Date last visited: September 2023

Stadium information: https://umassathletics.com/facilities/mcguirk-alumni-stadium/2

Summary Review: 1 star (out of 5)

I've watched a lot of college football in a lot of different stadiums at all NCAA levels.  I cannot think of a stadium designed more poorly than this one.  The only way into the seating area is through the 4 corners of the stadium, which creates a logistical nightmare entering and exiting the seating area.  The press box is its own separate structure from the stadium; I have read this is due to building code issues with the stadium, which doesn't surprise me.  Restrooms are found only in adjacent buildings, not in the stadium itself.  Almost every stadium puts the concession stands behind or under the seating, but not here: they are actually located between the seats and the field!  Even though I was sitting in the 17th row, I felt miles from the action.  The video board is the smallest I have seen at an FBS stadium.  On the bright side, the audio system is quite loud and clear, and there are a couple of interesting food options at the concession stands.  That said, I have been to several smaller FBS stadiums (yes, I'm looking at you, Mid-American Conference) and some large FCS stadiums, and even though UMass has some spirited students and fans, this stadium's design is worse than any of them.  I feel rather confident in proclaiming this stadium design as the worst one in FBS.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: When I entered the stadium and saw the horrible stadium design, I was expecting a dreadful gameday experience.  As it turns out, I have actually had worse experiences in better stadiums.  The atmosphere is surprisingly lively with very high student attendance.  UMass has a good marching band that keeps the crowd engaged.  I enjoyed the environment despite some of the other problems described in this review.

Seating: almost entirely bench seating with no backs.

Field View: terrible because you are so far from the field.

Audio/Video: The audio is quite loud and clear.  The video board is tiny and hard to read.

Concessions/Hot Dogs: The hot dogs are plump and juicy with a slight smoky flavor.  They also have an area that serves barbeque, which is a nice addendum.

Pedestrian Flow: terrible because you can only enter the seating areas at the 4 corners of the stadium.  My game had a "lightning delay" due to a storm that was many miles away, and it took 30 minutes for the stands to clear.  If there was an actual thunderstorm bearing down on Amherst, people may have gotten struck by lightning before they could get out of the stadium.

Parking: substantially all of the parking is on the north side of stadium, which is not ideal for traffic flow or for parking close to the stadium.

Christenberry Fieldhouse in Augusta, GA

Basic Information

Stadium: Christenberry Fieldhouse

Location: Augusta, GA (33.47198, -82.05930)

Owner: Augusta University

Primary sport: basketball

Year constructed: 1991

Listed capacity: 3026

Review date: March 2023

Arena information: https://augustajags.com/sports/2021/6/16/information-facilities-christenberry-fieldhouse.aspx

Summary Review: 3.5 stars (out of 5)

Christenberry Fieldhouse has a well-deserved reputation of being an excellent Division II basketball arena.  The building resonates sound reasonably well, giving Augusta a strong homecourt advantage.  The seats on the sides are plastic chair back seats while the seats on the ends are bleachers.  The seats were a little tight and short for a fat and tall person such as myself, but just having chair back seats in a Division II arena is a plus.  The grade of the stands is low, so a given row of seats is further away from the court than you might expect.  Also, the audio system does quite well for seats close to the court, but it can be hard to hear if you are sitting in the back rows.  The video system consists of two small boards in corners, but just having a video system in a Division II arena is a plus.  A walking/running track around the mezzanine level gives fantastic pedestrian access, and there is free parking literally all around the arena.  In total, while this arena has some shortcomings, it stacks up very well relative to other Division II basketball arenas.

Detailed Review:

Gameday Atmosphere: I came here for a conference tournament, so I didn't get the full experience of an Augusta home game.  Sound seems to resonate well in this building, and I suspect the home court advantage is quite strong.

Seating: plastic chair backs except for bleachers in the ends.

Field View: The stands have a gradual grade, so you feel further from the court than you would expect.  Most seats offer good sight lines relative to their location.

Audio/Video: The audio is a little hard to hear if you are in the outer sections.  There are 2 small video boards in corners, but any video boards in a Division II arena are a plus.

Concessions/Hot Dogs: The concession choices are hot dogs, soda, popcorn, and candy.  The hot dogs have a mild fake smoky taste, and the bun is bigger than the hot dog.  The concession prices are fantastically cheap.

Pedestrian Flow: A walking/running track going around the mezzanine level provides excellent pedestrian flow inside the arena.  There are plenty of walkways around the outside of the building.

Parking: There is plenty of free parking all around the building.  The main entrance is at the northeast corner of the building, a fact that is not obvious as you drive in.